Episode 418

full
Published on:

4th Nov 2026

Bad Vibes

Can you tell whether someone is trustworthy from the moment you meet them? We often feel that we can spot a wrong ’un almost instantly, but how reliable are those gut instincts — and what does the evidence say about our ability to judge other people’s character?

In this episode, Fraser, Nick and Peter explore the psychology of bad vibes, starting with a classic exchange from Lord of the Rings between Frodo and Strider about seeming fairer and feeling fouler. From there, the conversation examines what research tells us about first impressions, lie detection, facial features and the traits associated with dishonesty.

The discussion also explores why we may be more likely to trust people who seem happy, competent or charming, why entitlement and greed may be more revealing indicators of dishonesty, and how our own confidence in judging character can mislead us.

Links:

The hobbits discuss Strider's intentions.

First impressions happen very quickly.

We are not very good at detecting lies.

A small number of people are responsible for the majority of lies.

We are only modestly good at detecting trustworthiness in faces.

HEXACO including the honesty-humility dimension.

The overall evidence for accuracy in trustworthiness detection is 'mixed'.

First impressions: making up your mind after a 100-ms exposure to a face



This podcast uses the following third-party services for analysis:

Podtrac - https://analytics.podtrac.com/privacy-policy-gdrp
Transcript
Speaker A:

Hello and welcome to the Cognitive Engineering Podcast brought to you by Aleph Insights and produced by me, Fraser McGruer.

I'm here with Nick Hare and Peter Coghill of Aleph Insights.

On this podcast we look at a wide range of topics from an analytical viewpoint.

And today we're discussing bad vibes.

Nick, go for it.

Speaker B:

Well, let's all retire to the dark and smoky atmosphere of the Prancing Pony.

Yes, that's right.

We're in the world of Lord of the Rings and the Hobbits, who of course are on this kind of important mission to save the world, are being chased by the Dark Riders and Sauron spies and they meet the mysterious Strider.

And Frodo is.

They're discussing whether or not they should trust him.

And Frodo says, I think one of Sauron's spies would well, seem fairer and feel fouler, if you understand.

I think that is an absolutely brilliant bit of writing.

And just in case you think it was a one off, Strider replies, I see I look foul and feel fair.

Is that it?

All that is gold does not glitter.

Not all those who wander are lost.

He was very good, wasn't he?

Old Tolkien.

Speaker A:

I like that last bit.

Speaker B:

So, Frodo situation we've all been in, do I trust this guy?

Speaker C:

Right.

Speaker B:

And I think that Frodo's observation is so spot on.

This idea of he'd seem more superficially friendly, but also there would be some feeling of him being foul, which we are talking about today, the bad vibes.

So I think we want to discuss what are the things that give people bad vibes and whether or not they're correct.

But first of all, let's just cover some of the evidence about how good we are at detecting bad vibes.

And you might think, quite rightly, well, how on earth do you measure that?

How do you know what actual vibes someone should have?

How do you know what.

Whether a judgment is correct.

Well, actually, it turns out there's quite a lot of good ways of doing that.

Speaker A:

Let's just do a quick survey right now.

Really superficial.

And we'll bring back to it later.

On a scale of 1 to 10, I think we're talking about how good are you spotting a wrong un.

Right.

Speaker B:

I think that's the question.

Give us an amount of time within.

How much time?

Speaker A:

Oh, instant.

Speaker B:

You mean bump into on the street?

Speaker A:

Well, not even just bump into, but you meet someone new for the first time.

Speaker B:

Right.

So let's say 10 seconds in.

Speaker A:

Yes.

Okay.

How good on a scale of 1 to 10, one terrible at spotting a wrong and 10 brilliant at spotting a wrong.

And how good on a scale of 1 to 10, do you think you personally are?

And we'll come back to this later.

Speaker B:

Yeah, I'm say 5 out of 10 in that my first impressions are just no more or less likely to be correct than chance, I think.

Speaker A:

Yep.

Okay.

Speaker C:

Peter, I'm pretty terrible.

Not worse than chance.

So 5.

Speaker B:

But yeah, worse than chance would be.

You tend to find untrustworthy people more trustworthy people.

Speaker C:

Yeah, yeah.

So I say no worse than chance.

But my mitigation is I assume everyone's wrong until it's true.

Speaker B:

Peter's priors are really.

Speaker C:

Yeah, that's my safeguard.

Speaker A:

Okay.

I hopefully, I hope I've made it through the filter.

The Peter filter.

Speaker C:

Yeah, you're getting there, Frank, the jury is still out.

Speaker A:

I'm gonna be bold here.

I reckon I'm eight and a half, nine.

Speaker B:

Okay, well, let's see if we can convince you or not.

Speaker A:

But.

And then if I've, if I've got like a week, I reckon I'm a 10 out of 10.

But we'll see.

Speaker B:

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Well, I think by which time they've.

Speaker C:

Stolen all your money.

Speaker B:

Yeah, the evidence would back you up on that.

Actually, the, the, the, the interesting thing about all this is the evidence actually points in a really interesting direction, which we'll get to.

But so, so how do we measure this?

So the, the.

Obviously to try and do this in a controlled way, you need to have a measure of how bad someone's vibes actually are.

So we can work out how good we are at detecting it.

So you can do things like get.

Find photos of people who are criminals versus not criminals, for example, or video, you know, of people who are guilty of crimes.

That kind of things.

You've got criminal, you can find criminals and take pictures of them, right.

Speaker A:

You've got CCT of them breaking into a bank.

Speaker B:

That's when you go, yeah, I got.

Speaker A:

Bad feeling about that guy.

Speaker B:

Then you've got whether or not someone reciprocates trust in an economic experiment.

So you can do these experiments where someone.

So for example, there'll be a game where I give you some money.

You are then able to add to it or by doing something or potentially steal from it, and then you give me the money back.

Right?

So there might be like.

Well, you get to invest it at a rate that only, you know, and it might be that.

That rate times it by 10.

But you tell me it's only gone up by double and give me the money back.

So you can measure people's trustworthiness or, well, let's say willingness to reciprocate trust,.

Speaker A:

Which just as a quick sidebar, that sort of feels a bit like the question I asked you guys.

Feels like it assumes we're good guys.

But is there a correlation between ah, but are you a wrong and yourself and on what scale and how good at wrong UN's are spotting wrong and right.

Speaker B:

So lots of really interesting stuff there.

Yeah.

Then we have honesty.

So that's when someone.

You know, psychologists are pretty devious.

So.

So they will give people the opportunity to deceive what they think of as deceiving the experimenter, for example, so they might secretly observe someone's performance on a test and they'll say, right, you market yourself and then you could.

Then you tell us how you got on.

And some people just lie at those kinds of things, even though they didn't, they weren't aware they were being observed, for example, so that you can do that kind of thing.

Then there are things like infidelity which are relatively measurable.

And then of course, if you have much more time, you can actually measure someone's.

If you've got time to sit down and actually observe someone over a period of time, you can measure things like agreeableness or aggressiveness.

So how good are we at spotting these things?

There's a massive, really big.

So Bond and DePaulo did a really big meta study.

So they looked at about 200 other studies overall, 25,000 people.

When you put them all together about detecting lies.

So this is where someone tells them the truth or tells them a lie in various different setups and they are allowed to use the information that they see the person telling them.

That's all.

So.

So the person who is telling, giving the claim, making the statement, knows whether they're lying or not and the.

The judge has to work out if they're lying.

What do you think the accuracy was?

Speaker A:

It's going to be pretty awful.

Speaker B:

Yeah.

Speaker C:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

On average, 54% accuracy.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Which is.

Speaker B:

Chance is 50%.

I don't know if your maths is up to understanding why, but let's just chances.

50% In this case.

And that boils down to a 61% chance of identifying a, a truthful sentence as true and a 47% chance of identifying a lie as a lie.

So actually they are sort of more.

We're more likely to accept these things as true.

Basically.

A lie is more likely than not to go undetected which is interesting.

Then we have accuracy in facial trustworthiness impressions study by Fu et al.

This is where they just had to look at someone's face, picture of their face.

What do you think?

Speaker A:

I wouldn't be surprised if this was worse than useful.

I would expect.

Speaker B:

Oddly, there's a very, very slight correlation between people's judge of facial trustworthiness and actual trustworthiness.

Speaker A:

Interesting.

Speaker B:

Very slight 2% shared variance.

Which means of all the variation, if you know that someone's predicted, you know it'll shift, it'll shift them from being trustworthy, from being, you know, 50% to being 51%.

So it is slightly predictive.

People's judge of trustworthiness.

Very, very slightly predictive, but really not worth operationalizing.

When you allow people, the more time you let someone observ.

Interact with them, the more accurate that goes up.

So by the time they've had five minutes of observation of someone, it becomes the predictive relationship between the judgments and the trustworthiness actually becomes moderate.

Like statistically starts to become significant, which is interesting.

So the, the, the upshot in terms of performance is that are really like instant first impressions.

Those bad vibes or good vibes are not predictive.

Stop using them.

Can't really tell if someone's lying.

Very, very slight chance of being, you know, of detecting a true statement rather than a lie.

But not, but not very much.

But after the more interaction we can have with someone, we get much, much better.

What's odd to me is the fact that we make judgments so quickly which are unreliable.

I mean to some extent we're going to have to, but that, that can be overwritten by our subsequent experience.

Yeah.

Speaker C:

And there's a strong bias effect as well when meeting people.

think It's Willis and Todorev:

You form a judgment within 100 milliseconds of meeting someone, which is quicker than your thought happened.

So quicker than you realise that you've made that judgment.

But it has a very strong anchoring effect as well.

So that initial snap judgment, you have to work quite hard against it to change your opinion.

Speaker A:

But one would have thought there must be some kind of evolutionary purpose to that.

One would have thought or.

Speaker B:

Yeah, I think we'll get, we will probably get onto the kind of game theory side of it, which I think is really interesting.

But I think if this is the study.

Yeah this, this is the first impression study and they used computer generated faces.

So obviously here they don't have a truth, they're just finding out how Quickly people come to these judgments.

There isn't a truth here.

So it's not like these computer generated faces.

So they're not able to say whether those judgments are accurate in inverted commas.

But what they can do is work out what it is that's driving that first impression.

Speaker A:

Right.

Speaker B:

And there's a very clear, very clear indicator which is this.

Do you look happy or angry?

Speaker A:

Okay, so this is what I want to just.

I just want to frame this for a moment.

We've talked about how good we are at doing this, and the answer is, first of all, we're not.

And two, doesn't stop us.

But it doesn't stop us.

We're not as good as we think we are.

Right.

Related to that.

And also then, and Peter sort of talked a little bit about how quick are you sometimes doing this?

Right.

But now we're talking about, well, what data is there available on what we do?

Speaker B:

What does it turned out that, that we're actually using to form these.

What is driving that snap judgment?

And it is so apparently basically happy versus angry.

That is what drives or seems to.

From the things that they looked at, the traits in the faces that they vary.

That seemed to be basically it.

So they, I think they called that emotion over generalization.

Because we are using a sort of transitory mood to make personality judgments, which in other contexts is a bit like the fundamental attribution error.

When we're in, for example, a bit of a bad mood, we tend to blame external circumstances.

So we tend to say, oh, you know, because I've had a really stressful morning or whatever.

But when someone else in a bad mood, we tend to explain it with their personality.

So we go, well, they're just a grumpy kind of sod.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Yeah, interesting.

Speaker B:

So it's me.

I mean, to me this is not surprising at all.

It's interesting how quickly it happens, but it makes, it makes sense from the other ways that we know people, people tend to attribute to having said that.

And obviously there is a correlation between someone's propensity to be happy versus angry and their personality.

I mean, yes, you can find a happy person at a bad spot, but it's just less likely than if that person is a grumpy.

Speaker C:

It's a costly signal, isn't it, to be happy, to be outwardly happy.

Speaker A:

But what about if it's someone who's really happy going around slaughtering seal puppies or something?

Speaker B:

Yeah.

Speaker C:

And they're really happy, deliriously happy, with their bl.

Speaker A:

Bloodstained tunic yeah, but also one thing, I'm guessing the study or studies that you're citing, it sounds like it's like someone looking at computer generated image.

Speaker B:

That's right.

Speaker A:

It's a very narrow channel, very narrow media that we're using there.

There must be other stuff around.

Speaker B:

Yeah, well, I mean, but the interesting thing is that we do still nevertheless we don't.

Our brain doesn't go, well, I don't know, you know, I don't know what that is.

If you show someone an unfamiliar object, we don't immediately jump to the conclusion that it's a banana.

We just go, I don't know what that is.

But whereas when it comes to trying to judge someone's character from their face, we do it, we just instinctively do it.

Right, interesting.

this study, hartwig and bond:

So it's got a bit more credibility.

But they found that the things that seemed to make people appear untrustworthy were appearing incompetent.

So if someone seems incompetent, we don't trust them.

Kind of makes sense.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

Like I'm not going to give you like Chris's famous test of which I failed of would I trust this guy to post a letter for me, you know, then appearing ambivalent.

So if someone appears sort of not interested in you or what you're talking about, then we tend to use that to think that they're likely to be untrustworthy.

Eye contact is an interesting one because people think that eye contact makes a difference to their judgments about someone.

Like if someone is not looking at them that they.

People say, well if you know, if someone's got eye contact with you, then I tend to find them more trustworthy.

But apparently they don't.

People don't use that.

Like there's no correlation with eye contact and the trustworthiness that someone judges someone to have voices.

Higher pitched male voices seem more trustworthy apparently.

And it turns out another indicator that actually is true is wide faced men.

Beware the wide faced man.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

So it turns out that people with wider faces are less likely to reciprocate in economic games.

I don't think he's a wide man.

I think he's quite wide faced.

I think we should do some objective.

Speaker A:

I just want to say I'm very narrow faced but let's keep going.

Speaker B:

You can say that.

And not only that, but people actually do make judgments based on the width of someone's face.

So I report that mainly because not very much else comes out as useful like in the literature.

There's almost nothing else where people can say this thing correlates.

This easily observable thing correlates with trustworthiness.

And I should say to all those wide faced men out there, it is a very small correlation.

But it's interesting that people do actually use it.

Like when you show people lots of faces and ask them who they trust, they don't.

They're less likely to trust wide faced men.

Okay, interesting.

And the question is, does Tolkien tell us anything about the width of Strider stroke Aragorn's face?

Speaker A:

Right, so.

But I think what you're leading up to.

Speaker B:

Oh yeah, don't trust Brian Blessed, a big booming white faced man, at least trustworthy.

Speaker A:

I trust him.

Speaker B:

Right, that's because you know him now.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

But if you just met him, if you just met Brian Blessed I probably.

Speaker A:

Think he's a bit too.

Speaker B:

Bit much.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

But in the.

Down an alleyway or something, you're probably a bit scared of Brian Blessed and I think you might be right to be.

You'd say this man's got a deep voice and he's got a very wide face.

Speaker C:

Yeah.

Speaker A:

And it'd be quite scary how loud he is in a quiet place.

Speaker B:

Anyway, Strider.

Strider has a pale stern face in which there is a pair of green gray eyes.

And he's described as lean, dark tall and weather beaten.

So I think he's a narrow faced man.

I think Strider straight out one is a narrow faced man and I think the.

They didn't.

The hobbits don't say.

Well, I think a servant of Sauron would have a wider face.

I think they should have.

Speaker C:

Yeah.

Speaker A:

But also I think ye.

I think orcs have probably got quite wide faces.

Speaker B:

Elves, they definitely are pretty narrow, thin faced.

So it turns out we're all onto something there.

Speaker A:

So look, but here's a question then.

This is the stuff that we do seem to use.

Speaker B:

Yeah.

Speaker A:

What should we use?

Speaker B:

Yeah, I mean this is.

And the answer is sadly.

So just to zoom back in time a little bit, I went to school with a really good friend of mine, Andrew and he had a twin, non identical twin called.

Well I won't give the name of the twin, let's just call him Harry.

Right.

Speaker A:

Have you just given the name of the.

Of the person?

Speaker B:

Yes, but, but people with Andrew got a twin brother are going to be.

There's lots of those.

But anyway, let's say Harry the twin brother was the.

He was the genuinely the evil twin.

Speaker A:

Okay.

Speaker B:

Identical twins or no, non Identical, which is crucial to the, the upshot really.

But to the extent that Harry once stole his own video player.

Right.

Which mystified me, I was like, well how I understood, I wasn't naive enough to not understand stealing someone else's video player and selling it for me.

But I was baffled by the idea that you would steal your own video player and sell it for money.

And that's what he did.

He stole his family's video player, sold it for money.

Yeah, he was a real wrong in this.

I'm calling Harry.

Andrew had a very smiley, red haired kind of face.

And Harry, the evil twin had a wide face, wide round face and two little piggy eyes very close together and dark hair.

Right.

Now in my mind, I think the reason that I'm bringing this up of course, is that I was determined to find evidence that people with their eyes too close together are more likely to be untrustworthy.

But it turns out that all physiognomy really isn't true.

Except for the whole wide face thing.

Also, I mean obviously there is some correlation between, kind of, between facial characteristics and things like dominance.

You know that there is a correlation between testosterone and developmental factors.

And those kinds of things, they do influence your, the way you look.

But sadly like when it comes to your personality, your trustworthiness, there isn't all of those things.

I was really hoping to discover that eyes too close together equals untrustworthy.

So if that won't work, basically you can't really just look at someone and decide I trustworthy they are.

But if you spend a bit of time with them, by which I mean a few minutes, very quickly you get a bunch of things which you, which you can use to determine how trustworthy.

Speaker A:

Go on.

Speaker B:

Well, are they trustworthy or not?

Have they stolen something from.

Well, so I think you get other.

Speaker C:

Indicators like how they, how they speak, how they interface with you.

Are they un.

Unwarrant, you know, are they overly charming or they have got unwarranted confidence.

Speaker A:

Is there a kind of.

You say like unwarranted and you said something else that implied a miscalibration.

Speaker C:

Yeah, you're somebody who's sort of overly charming to you.

So what do they want?

If somebody's being, you know, is being like confident for no apparent reason, it's like well, are they just.

Speaker A:

Well.

Speaker B:

But this might be a bit petery to be honest because the evidence I looked at suggests people are actually really bad.

They were aware of.

People are aware of psychopaths, they're aware of people who are superficially charming, but they're no good at actually detecting them.

Like the whole point about psychopaths is they don't appear superficially charming, they appear charming.

Speaker A:

Well, psychopaths are very particular class of wrong and right.

Speaker B:

Yes.

Speaker A:

And that's.

Speaker B:

They're the ones, they have their own.

You don't want to get.

Yeah, but what I'm saying is like we are bad at picking up, not in any individual necessarily, but in general we are just bad at noticing psychopaths.

The thing that does work, right, so, and this is there's a model of personality called Hexaco which is.

And then one, it's like six factors.

One of them, which is the one we care about is called honesty, stroke, humility.

And that is a bunch of things that are all correlated and which correlate to your likelihood to be honest versus to cheat.

So people who score low on that are more like to exploit others for advantage or to cheat or to generally behave dishonestly.

And so that's great because it means we can look at some of the things which aren't directly honesty but which correlate with it.

And they are entitlement, which is great because now, now I've got a reason to dislike people who are self entitled.

So this is people expecting special treatment or expecting exemptions from rules, instrumental attitudes.

So seeing relationships as opportunities for advantage, being prepared to benefit at someone else's expense and crucially putting a high value on wealth and status.

Greed.

Speaker A:

Nice.

Speaker B:

Okay, so those things correlate with being less likely to be honest.

Speaker A:

But also those things I think are relatively easy spot as you've said as time goes on.

But they're difficult in the first instance,.

Speaker B:

Maybe.

I think, I think the key thing is that people are gonna find it hard to mask those unless they're doing it consciously.

These are things that you're gonna see in interactions if you're with someone.

You know, it's one of the things that people always say, you know, what gives?

What's a red flag on a first day?

And it's always if they're rude to the waiter.

And I think that's right.

Speaker C:

They're obsessed with your clothes or your watch or something.

Speaker A:

Yes, exactly.

Speaker B:

So yeah, as I said, it seems like we're not very good at detecting the dark triad traits.

Basically past behavior, people.

I know this is kind of obvious, but people are fairly persistent.

Like people are not situationally dishonest.

Like people are generally just people who are dishonest think they are.

People who are dishonest think, oh well, I Had to lie to get out of that situation or whatever.

But actually, you know, people who are like that don't realize that most of us go through life just not doing that.

So.

And I mean, that's true in a lot of.

I was looking at.

Well, what's the.

Actually how many people are wronghands?

Speaker A:

Oh, it's a good question.

How do you know?

What do you reckon?

Speaker C:

But I reckon like, ooh, oh, about 95% of them.

Speaker B:

Right, so Peter's got a very high prior.

95% Of people fall below his very high bar.

Speaker A:

I'm gonna just take Rongan to mean someone I shouldn't trust, who in a low level kind of way, low stakes, might betray my trust, let's say.

But in quite a low stakes way.

I reckon I'm gonna go like between 1 and 5%.

You're good.

Speaker B:

You're really good.

That's exactly what the evidence suggests.

Okay, so just looking at a few indicators, that number crops up a lot.

Right, so about 9% of people are responsible for 50% of crime and about 5% of people in total are the repeat offender group.

So people who are, you know, we love it.

Yeah.

And about 7% of men have been imprisoned by the age of 47%.

There you go, that's your 1 in 20.

Well, you don't mix with them, do you?

Speaker A:

No.

That's a crazy high number.

Speaker B:

Yeah, but you're probably down the pub in Sawbridgeworth.

No, not.

Where do you live now?

Grantham in Fokingham.

Yeah.

You're going to be mixing with a few people who've probably done a bit of time and they're reformed now, aren't they?

Speaker A:

Probably.

Speaker B:

They're a nice guy, but should you really trust them?

Who knows?

But the point is that there is a small number of people, but it's not nothing.

So I think this brings us on to the whole sort of strategy side of this because of like wrong wrongedness is persistent.

So actually if you have the best evidence you can get is has this person lied?

Like someone who lies about something and you know it.

There you go, the brilliant evidence.

They're not going to be lying with you but.

Or, you know, lying about something else but telling the truth to you.

They're not.

It's like, it's like, you know, in the same way, don't trust a cheater, you know, someone who cheats on their wife to be with you.

Well, don't expect them to stay faithful to you.

And it's the same with this.

Like, if you see evidence that someone is doing some small act of dishonesty like, I don't know, like stealing from.

Stealing from the collection plate in the church.

Well, don't trust them.

You know,.

Speaker C:

Savings.

Speaker B:

Right, exactly.

Speaker C:

So.

Speaker B:

So I think.

Which is interesting, and it's interesting that we are actually pretty good at picking that up.

Speaker A:

Yeah, Look, I think a couple of things.

Not time for my first point, but we're treating these characteristics, these properties as static and I'm not sure if they are or not.

And I think they can change over time.

Speaker B:

Consistent rather than static.

Yeah, let's say that.

Speaker A:

Yeah, I think they might be more malleable, flexible, depending on a number of things, including behaviors of other people with that person.

Speaker B:

Right.

Speaker A:

But I don't want to go down that too much, but something I do want to talk about is me.

Speaker B:

Yeah, great.

Your favorite topic.

Speaker A:

Yeah, absolutely, everyone's favorite topic.

Because one thing, you could sort of go through all these kind of strategies and figure them out or ask a mate Fraser along with you.

Right.

Not sure about someone because I'm good at this.

Speaker B:

Right.

I've got some evidence on people's ability to judge, their own ability to judge people.

Speaker A:

I suspect this might correlate with that episode we did on how funny you are or not.

And I know what I thought about how funny I was, but it didn't actually tally with facts.

Speaker B:

Yes.

I think.

I don't know if we've ever done one on the Dunning Kruger effect, but.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

So let me tell you the evidence before you tell me why I'm wrong about you.

Right.

Speaker A:

I mean, we can do it the other way around, but.

Go on, go on, you go.

Speaker B:

So in those.

In that lie detection study of 25,000 judges, eventually, right.

It turns out that there aren't people who are better lie detectors across the board.

No one was better.

Like, you know, there weren't anyone who'd spotted 90% of the lies.

Speaker A:

How did they.

Speaker B:

Everyone did kind of, kind of a bit better than chance.

There weren't some people who were on chance and some people who were getting it right 90% of the time.

There weren't some small number of people who were like really, really super good at spotting lies.

Right.

So that's not.

Speaker A:

How did the experiment work more.

Speaker B:

This is a meta analysis, so there'd be lots of different studies.

What I'm saying is that, okay, so the judgments that people make are correlated by.

To the person being judged and not the judge.

Right.

So in other words, to go back to the sort of facial studies for Example, the judgments that people made.

There weren't some people who were better at doing it across the board.

The most of the variation was not in the judge's ability but in how close together someone's eyes were, for example.

So it turns out that people are converging on the same wrong things.

Right.

So.

So it, you know.

However, there are people who are better or better or worse judges of personality and it turns out that better judges of personality tend to be agreeable, socially skilled and psychologically well adjusted and people with more trust in others are better at detecting it.

They're not gullible.

So the interesting thing, if you tend to trust other people, you are less likely to be gullible.

You're better at judging other people's trustworthiness than someone who doesn't trust anyone.

The PETA types.

Speaker A:

Yeah, no, quiet.

Well, actually, everything you just said there.

This, I like this because, because it supports the.

Speaker B:

You think that's you, do you?

Speaker A:

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Oh, okay.

And we've got a little bit of evidence for that just now.

Speaker B:

Right.

Speaker A:

Because we talked about, you know, what I percentage I thought were untrustworthy and mine was quite low.

Peter's was very high.

And I'm saying I'm really good at judging people.

Speaker B:

I think you've got, you've got it more or less spot on in terms of the frequency of baddies.

Speaker A:

Yeah, but look, here's my, here's my.

Let me just.

I've got some examples, however.

Speaker B:

Sorry.

Speaker A:

Oh, sorry, there's more?

Speaker B:

Yes, there is some evidence that people who think they're really good at judging character are worse than people who don't think they're really good at judging character.

But that's just a Dunning Kruger thing.

But it has been looked at.

Speaker A:

What's this Dunning Krueger thing?

What's this?

Speaker B:

No, it's just, you know that, that basically people's perception of their own ability at something tends to mean that they're either completely terrible at it, so bad that they have no means of even understanding how bad they are or that they're really, really good.

Speaker A:

Yeah, yeah.

Speaker C:

You're generally overconfident.

How much you know about.

Speaker A:

Look, I've got some evidence to support my claims and some pretty damning evidence against my claims.

So what I've done is, whilst we're chatting, I've drawn up a list of enemies and feuds that I've had in my life.

Speaker B:

Have you got a little list?

Speaker A:

I do, yes.

Speaker B:

Society offenders.

Right.

And they'll none of them be missed.

Let's have it then.

Speaker A:

So.

And at the outset, I think the key vulnerability to what I've got here is bias.

Right.

Like post bias, as it were.

Okay.

That what I'm saying.

Hey, it's like this.

It actually wasn't like that.

Okay.

So.

And just some examples, right.

Speaker B:

People who talk on the speakerphone on the bus.

Speaker A:

No, no, no, I don't mind.

Oh, okay.

So I'm not gonna.

I've written their names, but I'm not gonna say them.

But I've just thought of, like some major wrong UN's in my life.

Speaker B:

Right.

Speaker A:

Okay.

Where I've judged whether I've got it wrong or right.

And I would say it's difficult to go into here, but certain events and certain things happened which objectively people would go, that's a wrong.

Okay.

And how close was I or not to feeling this out initially?

So there's one person who actually is.

Was probably.

I can't remember the difference to a sociopath and a psychopath, but lots of maid, I think.

Right.

Okay.

Lots of other people sort of came same conclusion to me as this person was a sociopath and that person.

The signs were there pretty early on and I should have known, but I didn't.

But because I wanted something too much.

Speaker C:

Right.

Speaker A:

Which is there was a great.

I didn't want something from them, but I wanted to believe what I wanted to believe.

Speaker C:

Yeah.

Speaker A:

Okay.

But my God, that was an awful.

Speaker B:

Well, they're good at that.

Speaker A:

Well, yeah, that's the point.

They were.

So there was one person who kind of came into our lives a bit.

And I would say this is the only time ever where I've just been completely flummoxed and wrong where I thought this was basically a nice person.

And it turned out it's not that they were not nice.

Maybe they were just very, very untrustworthy.

And I was flabbergasted when I found out.

Okay.

And the signs were just not there.

So that one I do not know.

Speaker B:

Okay.

Speaker A:

Okay.

There was one person I worked with, had a long running feud and it took about a week.

At first I thought, yeah, it's an okay person.

And then a week later I just realized, no.

And my God, were they awful and made my life hell.

Okay.

And I'll talk about why they were such an awful persons, particularly to me.

Okay.

Speaker B:

I'm not bitter because it's interesting if.

Speaker A:

I bet.

Speaker B:

If we had them.

Speaker C:

So those are all the people that live in your town?

Speaker A:

Every.

Every place I live.

Like, they will hate me everywhere.

Yeah, it's you know.

Yeah.

And I can think of actually someone very similar to that in another workplace.

Very similar and a long running feud.

Now in terms of just two other examples.

Speaker B:

Well, are they just all like.

And this is the other person I met and they were horrible.

Speaker A:

No, no, no, no, no, no.

Speaker B:

Okay.

Speaker A:

Because a list of people who instantly I thought, nah, yes, you're not right.

I mean, and I think I've been subsequently produced.

Right.

I mean endless.

So, so many people.

But then finally I can think of one false positive or positive false positive where someone I thought not sure about you.

And actually and I was asked like what do you think about that person?

Yeah.

And then actually just pretty quick, I would be wary.

Speaker C:

They might just be playing the long game.

Speaker A:

Well, that's a hell of a long game.

I've known about six years now.

Speaker B:

Yeah, okay.

I mean, I mean, but, but so some misses, some hit.

Speaker A:

No, nearly all.

I would say instantly.

Mostly nearly all hits within a week.

Hundred percent hits.

Speaker B:

Yeah, yeah.

I mean instantly probably.

Speaker A:

And then one miss, one big miss.

Speaker B:

So, so I think I just want to make one final point before we wrap up, which is just this question of like what is the optimal detection rate, as it were.

Like what.

So we, we've got to be how confident do you have to be that someone is a wrong and to judge them harshly?

Right.

So now the question is what are the relative costs associated with getting this wrong now?

And I think I'm going to make the claim that trusting a scumbag is much more costly than not trusting a nice person.

Right.

I think we're talking orders of magnitude.

You let the wrong guy into your house and they'll rob you.

Right.

But if you probably, if you don't trust the right person, well eventually maybe you'll get a chance to get to know them better.

But at the same time you're not going to probably not going to lose anything.

It's unlikely that they're bearing some great opportunity.

At best they might be someone you would employ to cut your hedge or something.

Right.

So there's a massive difference between the type 1 and type 2 error costs here.

So all things being equal, we should be more likely to be making type two errors.

Speaker A:

Right.

Speaker B:

We should be on our guard.

We should be a bit untrust.

Untrusting.

People need to get, let's assume that people are, you know, in, have got a sort of 1 to 5% chance of being a wrong and they do have to work.

They've got to get up above the kind of 20% probability.

10, 20% Probability.

If there's that level of prevalence and you know, and if the costs are, let's say 10 times more.

If you get it, if you get it wrong and trust a bad person, then it ought to be the case that we, we are like rejecting a load of good people.

We should be more thinking that we're going to, you know, that someone's a bad person more often like potentially rejecting 10 times 9 good people for every one bad person we reject.

And that's an optimal thing to do.

So in a sense, like perhaps we should be a bit more like Peter.

Speaker A:

Yeah, yeah.

Speaker B:

But the point is that it's not very often you're in a hobbit type situation where you really have to make a snap judgment.

I mean, in their case, you know, if the, if, if it had been a servant of Sauron, well, he'd have got the ring and the whole of Middle Earth would have been destroyed.

So there's a lot riding on that and they haven't got a very long time.

Most of the time it's not as important as that.

And they've got more time to gather that info.

So, advice.

Don't trust your, your first impressions, very first impressions, but you can trust your impressions within about, you know, five to 10 minutes.

You're starting to get quite good.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

Speaker B:

And look out for small instances of being low in honesty because that is.

Speaker C:

Run experiments on people as well.

Give them opportunity to, to screw you over at small stakes.

Speaker B:

That's right.

Put them in, put them in your, in your drawing room and secretly observe them through a two way mirror to work out if.

Speaker A:

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker C:

With some money on the side.

Speaker B:

Yeah, that's right.

Speaker A:

Yeah.

We haven't got time for this, but just to, just to tantalize us a little, we're talking about pattern recognition there.

And there are certain types of people in society whose brains work in a certain way who are meant to be very good at that kind of stuff and very attuned to certain nuances.

But I'll just leave you with that for a moment.

Right.

That's a kind of advert as well, by the way.

So we're done, right?

Do you know what I'm all about?

Speaker B:

Yeah, go on, let's wrap it up.

Yeah.

Speaker A:

So you've been listening to the Cognitive Engineering podcast brought to you by Aleph Insights and produced by me, Fraser McGruer.

If you haven't already, please like and subscribe.

We aim to release an episode every week or two.

If there are any topics you'd like us to cover, please email us at podcast@alephinsights.Com.

Thanks as always for listening.

Until next time, goodbye.

Show artwork for Cognitive Engineering

About the Podcast

Cognitive Engineering
Welcome to the Cognitive Engineering podcast.
Welcome to the Cognitive Engineering podcast. Occasionally coherent musings of Aleph Insights. We hope you like listening to them as much as we like recording them.

About your host

Profile picture for Fraser McGruer

Fraser McGruer